We have time to watch and discuss one version of this scene today (we will not watch the Mel Gibson version which I mentioned yesterday). Watch the version linked below (both parts). This scene presents a relatively "typical" interpretation of the scene: Hamlet stabs Polonius, he throws his mother around on the bed, he accuses her of being a "strumpet," he interacts with the ghost, and then finishes his conversation with his mother in a gentler manner. It doesn't emphasize an incestual relationship with Gertrude as other interpretations have, but still illustrates the anger and violence Hamlet displays towards his mother. Observe:
Kenneth Branagh version, part 1:
Part 2:
After you're done watching the scene, get into your book groups and discuss the following questions:
1.) After seeing this scene acted out, do you think this scene lends itself to an "Oedipal" interpretation? In other words, do Shakespeare's words seem to indicate sexual tension between Hamlet and Gertrude? Why or why not do you think so?
2.) Do you think this scene shows that Hamlet HAS, in fact, gone crazy? Why or why not do you think so?
3.) In this scene, Hamlet sees his father's ghost, but his mother doesn't-- even though, earlier in the play, other people besides Hamlet WERE able to see the ghost. Shakespeare gives us no clues as to why Gertrude can't see the ghost. Why do you think Hamlet can see his father, while his mother can't?
4.) Discuss your understanding of Hamlet's relationship with his mother after this scene. Do you think she's convinced he's crazy, or will she still have some faith in the mental stability of her son? Do you think Hamlet still feels any affection and kindness towards Gertrude after this? Will Gertrude distance herself from Claudius after Hamlet's accusations, or will Hamlet's accusations drive the two of them closer together? Hypothesize, and explain your reasoning.
